Aggressive treatment for whiplash does not promote faster recovery

Contact: Amy Molnar
amolnar@wiley.com
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Whiplash, the most common traffic injury, leads to neck pain, headache and other symptoms, resulting in a significant burden of disability and health care utilization. Although there are few effective treatments for whiplash, a growing body of evidence suggests that the type and intensity of treatment received shortly after the injury have a long-lasting influence on the prognosis. A new study published in the June 2007 issue of Arthritis Care & Research (http://www.interscience.wiley.com/journal/arthritiscare) examined whether the association between early types of care and recovery time shown in an earlier study was reproducible with whiplash compensated under tort insurance.

A previous study led by Pierre Côté, of the University of Toronto in Toronto, Canada, found that patients compensated under no-fault insurance had a longer recovery if they visited general practitioners numerous times and/or consulted chiropractors or specialists than if they just visited general practitioners once or twice. In the current study, the authors examined patterns of care for 1,693 patients with whiplash injuries who were compensated under tort insurance.

The results showed that increasing the intensity of care to more than 2 visits to a general practitioner, 6 visits to a chiropractor, or adding chiropractic care to general practitioner care was associated with slower recovery. “The results agree with our previous analysis in a cohort of patients compensated under a no-fault insurance scheme and support the hypothesis that the prognosis of whiplash injuries is influenced by the type and intensity of care received within the first month after injury,” the authors state.

They note that effective care, if medically needed, improves the prognosis of patients and that practice guidelines recommend treatment shortly after the injury. However, it may be that doctors responding to pressure from patients use treatments, schedule follow-up visits and refer patients to specialists when not medically needed. “This in turn may lead to adverse outcomes and even prolong recovery by legitimizing patients’ fears and creating unnecessary anxiety,” according to the authors. It is also possible that early aggressive treatment delays recovery by encouraging the use of passive coping strategies. “Reliance on frequent clinical care, a form of passive coping strategy, may have a negative effect on recovery by reinforcing the patients’ belief that whiplash injuries often lead to disability,” the authors state. They cite another study that showed that whiplash patients who used coping strategies such as wishing for pain medication or believing that they couldn’t do anything to lessen the pain had a slower recover than those who did not use such strategies.

Unlike the previous study, the current one did not show a slower recovery for patients who consulted a general practitioner and a specialist. This suggests that the insurance system (tort versus no-fault) can affect the association between certain patterns of care and recovery because it may influence how patients perceive their medical needs, the pressure they put on clinicians to be referred, and how insurers require them to legitimize their injury. The authors conclude that further trials “are essential to understand the influence of health care provision in preventing or facilitating disability.”

###
Article: “Early Aggressive Care and Delayed Recovery From Whiplash: Isolated Finding or Reproducible Result”” Pierre Côté, Sheilah Hogg-Johnson, J. David Cassidy, Linda Carroll, John W. Frank, Claire Bombardier, Arthritis Care & Research, June 2007; (DOI: 10.1002/art.22775).

FMS Global News

Tenderpoints

Source

Advertisements

About FMS Global News

Folllowing Rick Usher's death in December 2008, at his request in September of that year, I had agreed, as his principal contributor and an experienced journalist, to run the FMS Global News service due to his heavy commitments to music and raising research funds through this avenue. Following his sad and sudden death I hope to continue his work as he would have wished.
This entry was posted in Analgesics, Arthritis, Article, Awareness, Back Pain, Boston, Britain, Chronic Fatigue, Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, Chronic Insomnia, Chronic Multisymptom Illness, Chronic Myofacial Pain, Chronic Pain, Chronic Pain Disorders, Chronic Widespread Pain, Clinical, Clinical Pain, Europe, Feeds, Fibrohugs, Fibrohugs News, Fibromyalgia, Fibromyalgia Blogs, Fibromyalgia News, Fibromyalgia News Belgium, Fibromyalgia News Deutschland, Fibromyalgia News France, Fibromyalgia News Israel, Fibromyalgia News Italy, Fibromyalgia News Japan, Fibromyalgia News Jerusalem, Fibromyalgia News Korea, Fibromyalgia News Southeast Asia, Fibromyalgia News Turkey, Fibromyalgia News Wisconsin, Fibromyalgia Press Releases, Fibromyalia News Germany, FMS Global News, Global News, Health, Health Care, Health Insurance, Hypersensitivity, Invisible Illness, Invisible Illnesses, Medical, Medical Insurance, Medical Journals, Medical Research, Medical University, Myofacial Pain Syndrome, Neurotransmitters, News, News Australia, News Belgium, News Canada, News France, News India, News Ireland, News Israel, News Italy, News Japan, News Jerusalem, News Korea, News Montreal, News Nigeria, News Norway, News Quebec, News Saskatchewan, News Scotland, News Spain, News Sweden, News Toronto, News Turkey, News UK, News Wisconsin, Nigeria, North Carolina, Ontario, Osteoarthritis, Ottawa, Pain, Pain Management, Pain Management Clinic, Pain Matrix, Philadelphia, Poor Sleep, Preventive Medicine, Rehabilitation, Research, Rheumatism, RSS, Sleep Disorders, Sleep Disturbance, Sleep Quality, Stockholm, Swedish, Syndromes, Temporomandibular Joint Disorders, Tenderpoints, Therapies, TMJ, Toronto, Universities, US, Virginia, Washington DC, World, World News. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s